102 Comments
User's avatar
Harald Gormsson's avatar

And very shortly we will all find out if AfD can actually govern effectively or not. Rhetoric and campaigning are easy, governing is not.

Spiff's avatar

I am sure they can learn on the job. At the moment Germany has no real alternative anyway since all the others are globalist shills.

Quakeress's avatar

They can't do a lot worse than the governing parties. And this is the next step towards an expansion of the party system - same as we had with the Greens. What a scandal THAT was when they first got into Parliament. Everybody was big mad and kept bewailing the loss of political culture, their radicalism etc. A few decades on parties were bending over to enter into a coalition with them. It's probable that AfD will have the same trajectory: get rid of their "Fundi" wing, become more respectable. We have to have parties that together represent every part of the political spectrum (except the insane fringe) - we can't just not represent 30, 40, 50% because the Berlin chattering classes dislike their ideas. Nature abhors a vacuum. CDU left a vacuum at the place to its right in the political spectrum. AfD has started to fill it.

EppingBlogger's avatar

I am not a German so I hesitate to take an explicit position on the parties in that country. I am pleased, however, to see the failed old political class being damaged and, I hope, it will be broken so new people can try to do better.

While it may be difficult for AfD to do worse than the others that will not be the standard the MSM applied. In the case of AfD and in the UK also Reform, a single error will be jumped in and criticised. I recommend rapid action so long as they have a plan. On ad hoc issues take it step by step.

Quakeress's avatar

I agree, MSM will report most unfairly on everything they do. However, this can't be helped, and MSM have lost much trust among the population. AfD (and also Reform) simply have to learn on the job and hopefully stick it out.

Julinthecrown's avatar

Right. Who listens/reads/believes the MSM anymore???

ZeroGravitas53's avatar

The Greens are part of the insane fringe. Pushing even more extreme versions of the policies that are part of the current economic problems faced by Germany. The problem exemplified by your post is you've tolerated them long enough that they're just part of the "decor" like that mold in the corners of the shower stall.

Danno's avatar

That's crap that politicians tell us to justify their salaries, benefits, and incompetence. Government has a guaranteed revenue stream and few actual responsibilities. The problem is competition for that revenue stream, which is called "politics".

Alex Starling's avatar

Yes, but if the AfD turn out to be bumbling normies, Mr Pistorius et al are presumably also going to find out that their hyperbolic rhetoric is somewhat ludicrous, and this won't reflect too well on any of the cartel parties.

Danno's avatar

All they have to be is "bumbling normies" and they'll easily outperform the cartel parties.

Tell's avatar

We have already seen that the ruling socialists can't govern, so what's your problem?

Pat Robinson's avatar

They can hardly do worse than utter freefall?

Matthew McWilliams's avatar

And they will be worse than the current crop of governors how?

Martin's avatar

Given how absolutely atrociously Germany has been governed the past 20 years, I would say it can't get any worse and we would even improve if we just assigned the job to random citizens every four years. The AfD actually has HUGE incentives to do well. They will do well.

air dog's avatar

I think it would be foolish to think any major political party can actually govern effectively.

Ray Noack's avatar

Slow and steady …nothing dramatic . nothing that calls attention

Thibaud's avatar

Campaigning is not that easy.

And governing can be quite easy. Meloni did pretty much nothing and remains the most popular Prime minister of Italy for the past 80 years.

Christine Summerson's avatar

Much appreciate E's updates and analysis.

ZuZu’s Petals's avatar

A glimmer of hope for the future. Good news is always welcome.

Potassium Enjoyer's avatar

Very enjoyable watching the English-language DW reportage on this yesterday, in which, amid clips of Siegmund and Rausch grinning and slapping each other’s backs hitlerishly, we see various benose-ringed and asymetrically-befringed leftists hyperventilating and blubbering that, yes, almost half the electorate voted for them, but they still don’t have the RIGHT

Robert C Culwell's avatar

Classic.....

...when the media refuses to acknowledge the real gravity of the issues facing the republic, compare the conservative point of view with the nazi party, again.

Sounds like the rank and file volk of the BDR are just about sick of it! 🇩🇪📺📰🎤📻 Good for them.

Epaminondas's avatar

It's amazing how everything the corporate media don't like just happens to be "fascist".

Spiff's avatar

Let us hope this is the beginning of real change towards tackling immigration and managed decline, and not a blip on the radar before the establishment crushes the populist right.

I hope other European states are taking note. There may yet be a democratic route out of this mess before the numbers are simply stacked against native Europeans.

Quakeress's avatar

This is a big slap in the face for Merz, who keeps defending the Brandmauer with all he's got, and in itself this is remarkable - CDU is not for nothing called a party that's basically nothing but a Club for Voting In Chancellors ("Kanzlerwahlverein"). To go an do expressly what the chancellor has expressly told them not to do - this is quite an outrageous thing to do for high-ranking party members. Of course SPD unpacks the parallel to Weimar conservative parties as "stirrup holders" of NSDAP. They profit if Christian Democrats uphold the Brandmauer. Christian Democrats do not. So, SPD is putting the pressure on.

Seb Thirlway's avatar

"Of course SPD unpacks the parallel to Weimar conservative parties as "stirrup holders" of NSDAP."

How depressing, and depressingly predictable. Newsflash for them: not everything which happens in Germany is Exactly The Same As That Stuff in 1933...

Quakeress's avatar

I think many of them really believe it is (Exactly The Same), but on the other the more strategic thinkers among them are smart enough to painfully squeeze the Christian Democrats whenever and wherever they can be squeezed. So it'll be "stirrup holders" till the end of time or until CDU stop feeling anguished and offended when being called thus.

John Davison's avatar

"pissed on the sacred firewall". Lol.

This could well be a seminal moment in European and World history. Will others follow the attraction of being Kingmaker?

Vote anyone other than AFD and you get even more expensive energy, German rearmament (that went well the last two or three times) more immigrants, the spectre if not an actual desire for WW3 and more German money being diverted to Ukraine.

Vote for the Right Wing Fascist Hitler loving party and you get leaders wanting peace with Putin and trade with Russia.

Very strange.

Pacific Observer's avatar

>>> ... money being diverted to Ukraine. <<<

LET'S NOT. Let's NOT pay obeisance to the narrative nabobs in London and DC who created this simulacrum of a country known as "Ukraine" out of whole cloth, with all the usual paraphernalia:

- shelling and murdering its own "citizens,"

- prohibiting the language spoken by MOST CITIZENS,

- forcing Russia into a war to defend its "near abroad" which the U.S. had expressly undertaken to honor.

The site of these crimes has always been known in English as _THE Ukraine_. The capital of THE Ukraine is Kiev.

THE Ukraine has no legitimate president. Instead, the Ukraine's former puppet president, the Russophone Vladimir Alexandrovich Zelenskiy (Владимир Александрович Зеленский) is still clinging to power as "acting" president.

Warmek's avatar

It isn't necessary, and is in fact counterproductive, to oversell it. Particularly when any number of the claims are simply incorrect.

Ukraine existed well before London or DC got involved, as evidenced by Kruschchev granting Crimea to that state long before any of the recent unpleasantness occurred.

Ukraine *did* in fact undergo a rather ugly process of "Ukrainization" as regards the use of the Russian language (which, so far as I can tell as an outsider, is about the distinction between speaking "Bostonian" or "Texan") which is bad enough, but the Russian speakers were not a majority. There's no need to exaggerate it.

I absolutely agree that in recent years, the threat of a "Kievan Missile Crisis" was a complete and utter own goal on the geopolitical playing field.

Pacific Observer's avatar

QUOTE: ... the Russian speakers were not a majority [in the Ukraine] ...

Taking the 1991 collapse of the Soviet Union as a point of departure, EVERYONE in the Ukraine (whether ethnic Ukrainian, Russian or other) had been educated in Russian from grade school through high school and beyond. Russian was the ONLY language that was seriously written, and the ONLY language used in formal dealings with government entities, in business transactions etc.

MI6 and the CIA have since WW II worked very hard to foment a "Ukrainian" identity and stir up resentment against Russia and all things Russian. These efforts were dramatically stepped up after 1991, and reached fever pitch after the MI6/CIA operation leading to the successful Maidan coup.

In this political climate (and given the Ukraine's long tradition of gangsterism), it is not surprising that many people living under the Kiev regime now CLAIM to use only Ukrainian. In reality, it is likely that most residents of the Ukraine - including a large proportion of those who regard themselves as ethnic Ukrainian - use Russian as their principal language when they have a choice.

The situation is perhaps comparable to Scotland - Scots emphatically do not regard themselves as English ("Sassenach") but proudly speak and write English in real life.

Donna's avatar

🥳

Ronda Ross's avatar

Thanks for the info. Germany, the 3rd largest economy in the world, has a lot of company. Brazil the globe's 10th largest economy, seems poised to join the club, along with France in the Spring, and England by the decade's end.

Much of Europe, Central and South America and the productive parts of Asia, are moving Right, as well. Let's hope they do not muck it up, like the Progressives they replace.

Kaycee's avatar

No so sure about England. I think they are much further along in their Islamist takeover. And the USA needs to take back their nukes, like they just removed their bombers from the air field that an attempt was made by backing of the Iranian regime. If Islam gets ahold of those nukes you can be rest assured they will use them. Trump needs to take them back my any means at his disposal, like yesterday!

Gary Edwards's avatar

Well USAID is gone. All of this commonsense thanks to Trump et.al.

Suzie's avatar

Things are getting spicy in Germany. Let’s Goooooo!

Seb Thirlway's avatar

"Yesterday, however, Rausch did not just get 44 votes. Instead he got 48 votes, which means that four CDU members broke ranks and pissed on the sacred firewall to help the AfD into their first Landtag presidency. "

ROFL!

I love the image. But though pissing on a Sacred Firewall is definitely sacrilege (iconoclasm?), doesn't pissing on a firewall actually make it more fire-resistant?

Henrybowman's avatar

Perhaps the firewall was constructed from all of Merz's unconsumed lithium pills.

Bizarro Man's avatar

Stuck together with cocaine mortar.

Robert Lawrence Kehrer's avatar

Does anyone there actually study history? In the same way the antifa people behave most similarly to historical fascists & Trump is undoing everything that could conceivably be similar to 1930 fascism, it is the non-AFD parties that are behaving most similarly to 1930 fascists. The AFD appears to be putting a stop to Germany’s sad decline back into totalitarianism.

Russell A. Paielli's avatar

I've said this many times before, but it bears repeating. The constant association of AfD or any non-globalist party with the Nazis is based on the Big Lie that the Nazis were "right wing". Until that lie is finally put to rest, the nonsense will continue.

National Socialism is Not Right Wing

How the deceptive mislabeling of fascism and Nazism distorts modern politics

https://russp.substack.com/p/the-false-flag-of-right-wing-fascism

jan van ruth's avatar

his words show that pistorius is the real fascist..

wmj's avatar

What sort of tangible action can an AfD state government take that will yield different results from states governed by legacy parties? I don’t know how much autonomy states have in the German system.

A year from now, can Sachsen-Anhalt be materially different or will people say “AfD talks big but when they govern they’re just like everyone else”?

Mark Bob's avatar

Two big things:

1. Get the climatist lunatics completely out of all parts of the state bureaucracy.

2. Cease all social spending directed toward giving Muslim immigrants cushy lives.

Chartertopia's avatar

But how much effect will that have? Do individual states actually control much of those?