245 Comments
User's avatar
Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

From my perspective as a Gen X German:

the official "Guilt Cult" made sense in the first few decades of the new republic. You cannot just pretend Germans did not just ostracize and kill many of their own citizens and start a world war causing mass death and destruction.

For my generation, there was already very little feeling of guilt, but rather a sense of empathy. I met several people who survived the camps, and had family members who didn’t.

However, I have never met a Millennial or GenZ who feels any guilt or even has much knowledge about the Nazis. It has become an empty phrase, much like "white guilt" or "the patriarchy."

The "never again" catchphrase long ago became an empty phrase to hit your political enemies with.

As you mentioned, it is similar in other countries. I lived in Sweden for a while, and they are proud of their country and their heritage. Yet, they make all the same demographic mistakes we do, and more.

But the myth of the guild cult is also used on the right as well. Some outside force made us do all the mistakes, and if we can just get rid of it we will be fine and it will be 1985 again.

Rikard's avatar

Can confirm this about Sweden; there's a Guilt Cult here too among many minds. "We have it so good, we must share our good fortune with the less fortunate or we are being bad people", essentially.

Which drives me mad with rage.

What we have, we the Swedes worked to have. We were given nothing.

Now, vile Volksfeind are giving it all away to undeserving scum-of-the-Earth, and we are supposed to tilt our heads and go "Coo, aren't we the goodest evar" and revel in our own goodness.

The Left wanted to smash the nation-state so that their idealised New Soviet Man can be created; the Right wanted to smash the nation-state so that they could turn people into interchangeable wage-slaves for capitalism.

And thus, multiculturalism and massmigration as an ethical [Good] was born.

Pat Robinson's avatar

Yes, what they are calling "privilege" is simply a people that works hard to build a wealthy high trust society.

There is no such thing as white privilege, Justin Trudeau is the exception that proves the rule, a sort of man who no one would ever have heard of except for his last name.

Thats really just nepotism.

But he remains they best example of the worst of Canada.

Rikard's avatar

It's as if there's some cloning-lab somewhere churning out copies of Tony Blair tweaked to local specs, and has been doing so for 20-30 years.

They sound alike, they think alike, they even look alike no matter if they are German or Canadian or Swedish or whatever.

Mitch's avatar

In the US we had the milk chocolate version for our historic "peculiar institution"

KHP's avatar

Alternatively, "White Privilege is Earned Privilege"

Pat Robinson's avatar

Or deserved.

The entirety of DEI and critical race theory is based on communist ideas, basically equality of outcome (instead of the sane option, equality of opportunity).

Equality of outcome, and cultural equivalence, are the base from which this flows, if certain people or cultures are doing worse it can only be because someone else is holding them down, via racism, privilege, etc whatever and the only solution is to destroy that which is actually working, so that the failed groups don't feel so bad.

The cultural equivalence thing is poison.

Ray Noack's avatar

Do the Swedish girls feel an obligation to get raped by a black Muslim ? For the “ greater good “

Throgmorton's avatar

Yes, apparently they do, and the men also.

Mitch's avatar

I think your analysis gets to the root of why deep down the powerful, though often coming from different places, have made this mass migration happen. It doesn't address the longer-term voting patterns of these new clients of the State, but I think this is implicit.

Jim Brown's avatar

Your parallel between Germany's "guilt cult" and America's "white guilt" is interesting. Both seem to have pushed their societies toward leftist politics.

AndyinBC's avatar

The whole "rich world", all of the so-called western liberal democracies, seem to be caught in the same trap.

Or infected by the same self-destructive terminal illness or plague.

Socialism.

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

Yes, California is extremely sad to see.

I had relatives in San Diego and visited beginning of the 80ies (from Germany). It seems like paradise, the American dream. And now to see what it has become of it.

Warmek's avatar

You have my most abject sympathy.

Serious question, to which there are many perfectly reasonable answers, but: Why haven't you moved elsewhere? Genuinely curious.

Ray Noack's avatar

The black man will get reparations from me when Hell freezes over .

Guiltless in Santa Barbara.

Warmek's avatar

The Black Man has *been* getting reparations from you likely your entire life, or at least since the 60's. What else do you think Welfare and Section 8 *are*?

Ray Noack's avatar

Correct …at the point of a gun ..aka Taxes .

Yet despite all that money the blacks still score 15 points lower than Whites on standardized IQ tests .

In fact you can go back to the Army Alpha Test in WW1 to find the exact 15 point difference , 1969 Jensen finds 15 points …1994 Hernnstein and Murray find …15 point difference.

Maybe the problem wasn’t “ nutrition “ after all .

Good point Warmek ….” Go ahead …ruin my day “ ..hahaha

Jim Brown's avatar

It's amazing how widespread the myth of collective guilt is, and how it is manifests in so many ways.

Mitch's avatar

you've been paying reparations your whole life, it just isn't itemized for you.

Matthew McWilliams's avatar

"White guilt" is a niche idea in the United States. Most whites don't feel it because most whites, such as myself, descend from people whose only association with slavery came from having served in the Union Army. The idea also has less purchase on the average white due to the fact that the descendants of the slaves my ancestors fought and died to free have become such a plague on the Country.

The idea is niche to upper class whites, most of whom wouldn't dream of living in a truly integrated community. The only reason the policies that flow from "white guilt" have any traction politically is the classic high-low alliance between those niche upper class whites and a vast reservoir of imported varieties of black and brown people.

Warmek's avatar

> The idea also has less purchase on the average white due to the fact that the descendants of the slaves my ancestors fought and died to free have become such a plague on the Country.

++

Ming the Merciless's avatar

White Guilt may be a niche idea in the US, few adults take it seriously, but it’s being force fed to kids in high schools and colleges. Most boys react to it with contempt and revulsion but girls are more receptive to it.

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

It is probably indicative of our rich, satisfied societies who are standing on the achievements of their ancestor and have become somewhat weak and morally ungrounded: it is easy to make us feel guilty and exploit us that way.

Appeal to our niceness.

No Hitler- (or Stalin, etc.) type would have any chance with us.

But people who say they are weak and demand our submission by empathy.

Our problems did not exist in the 1950ies, because people where a bit less tolerant, a bit more firm.

Ray Noack's avatar

I grew up in USA in 50’s and 60’s

There will never be a period like 1954-1963

Henrybowman's avatar

"Hey kids! What time is it?"

We never really knew until decades later.

Mitch's avatar

Before the "Great Society" programs set us on our path of destruction.

Ming the Merciless's avatar

In my experience 1970-90 was really great!

Henrybowman's avatar

Collective guilt is a basic and time tested lever of social control. The Church made great use of it for two millennia (Original Sin, as mentioned). Ayn Rand had choice and quotable words about how authoritarian governments "cash in" on it in Atlas Shrugged. The USA has its own version of it in the "slavery tale," despite more of our white folk dying in the war to abolish it than any other war in its history.

The best defense against the collective guilt button is to invalidate it entirely, refuse to accept that it applies to you. You are not responsible for either the sins OR the crimes of your parents, and you are definitely not responsible for the sins or crimes of people who were never your parents (because yours immigrated well after the event) but who simply happen to LOOK like them.

Especially when those pushing the guilt button invariably belong to the party that actually kept the slaves, then sicced their KKK on the ones that were freed.

Daniel Tufts's avatar

If only Balfour hadn't made his deal with a certain group, the US very likely would've stayed out and WWI would been fought to more or less a draw in 1917 hence no Versailles, no Weimar, no WWII, no super-evil moustache man. Once again, it's the Brits . . . and, you know, that other certain ethnicity/religion.

I'm so ashamed of my Anglo-Saxon blood I think I'll let savages take all I have to atone for Balfour.

Ray Noack's avatar

Good point . But I have no guilt .

The USA was duped into WW1 by arch villain Wilson and again by FDR

Wim de Vriend's avatar

I don't quite get the connection between the Balfour Declaration and Wilson's ill-considered intervention in WWI. Can you explain?

jan van ruth's avatar

i will say it for you : the jews....

Joseph Little's avatar

Both have been used by Leftist to grab power. Moral power, but also actual power. To do, by and large, absolutely stupid things.

The first sign that someone is NOT better than you is that they try to convince you they are better. And state it in rather sanctimonious terms.

What is the foundational myth of Communism and the other leftist causes?

“If God did not exist, he would need to be invented” is a neat little intellectual quote. So, they create their own myth.

First, the leftist were/are mad as hell, and unsuccessful.

So, they created an enemy (the usual long and tiresome list, which to them seems at least plausible, or, at least plausible to others of the now or then current day).

Then the leaders rouse up the rabble (the useful idiots), and every now and then have “a revolution”. But, sometimes the people (with or without the help of an easily “engineered” voting process) actually vote these idiots in.

To be a bit fair, life is rough, and there are things that might be called legitimate complaints. Except that everyone has plenty of them. And except that the leftist solution is very disproportionate to any one complaint. (The leaders know this, but are quite willing to use any crisis for power.)

Note also: the revolutionaries, sometimes more and sometimes less, eat themselves. Cf. The French Revolution, and others.

Of course, that’s where problems start to arise, mainly because these leftist are as incompetent as Karl Marx himself in being effectual and actually useful in the real world.

But, between (perceived) power and psychological suasion, they can and do, despite all evidence, remain in power for years. (Why do not some wiser and smarter people execute a counter-revolution? It seems a good revolution with talented people is very rare. I think only the American Revolution, ugly as it was, fits this kind of example. WHY we may well ask. Are good people too ready to suffer while evils are sufferable? Rather than, of course, still imperfectly and in an ugly way, rise up against a sea of troubles, and right the ship? Why do people not act sooner against these stupidities of the Left (ok, let’s include a few flavors: Stalinists, Maoists, Antifa. woke, progressive, climatists, AI doomer fools, Suicidalists, etc etc).

AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Notice how in the Christa Pike case Americans fell over backwards to condemn the white girl while painting her accomplices as "poor hard done by blacks" and a "poor hard done by Muslim and Satanist" who were rightly spared the death penalty that the white girl deserved. It makes a lot of sense when you consider that so-called "whites" in America have 3 times the black admixture that European whites have.

Matthew Hopkins's avatar

Ha Ha...no. What a stupid comment. "So-called "Whites". Where did you get that idea..out yer ass?

AwakeNotWoke's avatar

From the 2015 Bryc et al. study in The American Journal of Human Genetics (“The Genetic Ancestry of African Americans, Latinos, and European Americans across the United States”),

After excluding countries with historical Atlantic trade/port connections (Portugal, Spain, France, UK, plus Malta), the European figure is essentially zero within survey-error margins (0.04%). That's not so for Americans. The European comparison group shows substantially lower rates.​ The ratio is roughly 3.5× for American so-called "whites" (often rounded or described as “about three times”).

lsgv's avatar

I do agree with your point. I’m a boomer from BE and worked many years in Germany and many more with german companies and I’ve never met anything other than assurance, arrogance, self-aggrandising myths and in general, fat and round satisfaction. Never any doubt nor guilt, about anything, only the certainty of German culture. Which is kind of funny because in the mid 90s in Waldorf, HQ of the company I was working for, Friday afternoons were already the weekend and later, while working in Hamburg, I had to remind my German colleague workers that 9 o’clock is not 9:10. So much for stereotypes. But back to the argument, if there was any such thing as a guilt cult, why the Russian hate when Germany killed many more Russians than Jews? Is it because we don’t have the usual yearly run of Hollywood productions remind us of the Jews? Or because history has erased all those Russian deaths? Or because German accounting values Russians different than Jews? Even Kadja doesn’t know about them.

Ray Noack's avatar

Good point . In all 70 million died . Tens of thousands fried in Dresden and a million in Toyko by Curtis Le May , who turned to a fellow pilot and said “ we’d better win “

“ why Sir “ ….” Because we will surely be tried for war crimes , that’s why “…they knew

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

You worked at SAP? This is probable the epicentre of self-satisfaction...

---

The Russian-hate is strange to me as well, and I don't really understand it. t broke out very suddenly with the Ukraine war. IMO, very manufactured.

Pretending empathy with dead Jews is very easy in Germany, because there arent many Jews. And some have made it there businessmodel to be token Jews to support the systems. This is wh ou alway see the same in the media.

When I was young in the 70s/80s there were a number of big German-Jewish entertainers who dind't care about to be seen as Jewish and seldom mentioned it (but also didn't hide it). E.g. Hans Rosenthal.

Only after the 90ies, when almost all the old GErman Jews were dead, "fighting antisemtism" became fashionablr with the talking classes.

Probably similar with the cult about the American Indian which started onlx they were killed.

Ray Noack's avatar

It is not clear that Germany started WW2 . In 1939 Hitler wanted Danzig back . It was a port city with 95% Germans . It was taken from Germany at Versailles. England objected and John Maynard Keynes ( one of the negotiators) left in disgust and predicted precisely how it would unfold 20 years later . It was a “ border dispute “

Sure ,Hitler probably would have eventually taken all of Poland later . But no one knew that when ENGLAND declared war . Oh , declaring War did absolutely nothing because England did nothing and Poland was leveled. It is hard to imagine a worse outcome for Poland than the one caused by England .

80 years on , it’s time we started to challenge the foundational myths of WW2 .

Mitch's avatar

It's clear that Germany started WWII via their series of actions even prior to Poland - Austria and Czechoslovakia. They were set to revise all of the provisions of the Treaty of Paris that was forced on them. Further appeasement wouldn't have changed anything but the timing for Hitler's planned all along to invade Eastern Europe and Russia long before the Molotov/Ribbentrop agreement.

Ray Noack's avatar

When were they planning on landing on Santa Monica Beach ?

Throgmorton's avatar

Their allies destroyed a naval base in Hawaii.

Michelle Dostie's avatar

“Never again” filled most of my life. As a young schoolgirl realizing I was halfGerman, I wanted to keep that secret, but no longer. As antisemitism is rising again in the USA along with Marxism, the Never Again creed has vanished from much of the populace. Yet without the rise of National Socialism, which I’ve understood to be the result of the incredible inflation after WWI, the Treaty of Versailles and the need for a “hero” leader. I did understand Merkel’s immigration policies to be atonement for the history, so unnecessary.

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

You give Merkel too much credit. She didn't do anythiong without having her own gains in mind. She has no morals whatsoever.

Merkel of 2005 made big speeches the multi-culturalsim has failed and we should stop immigration.

Throgmorton's avatar

Merkel is the second worst German Chancellor ever. A close second.

Ray Noack's avatar

Funny how England doesn’t say “ Never again “ about Dresden

Michelle Dostie's avatar

It was primarily an American credo from the 50’s

Warmek's avatar

> if we can just get rid of it we will be fine and it will be 1985 again.

I mean, personally, I think I'd pick 1993. As a Gen X American, 1993 was a pretty bloody good year for me. The ever-present threat of nuclear annihilation had seemingly been vanquished, and NATO had not yet been used as a cudgel in places where it had no business yet. The future seemed damned bright, in 1993.

MAGRIETHA DU PLESSIS's avatar

The guilt cult is at work here in South Africa as well, but it seems that the "apartheid" will for ever be the reason for everything that is wrong in the country. It is used by both sides even my son that has become a German citizen when he married a German Mennonite, has it thrown against him in some circles in Germany. Maybe that the people doing that make themselves feel better because there is someone even more guilty?

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

South Africa was for decades the favourite villain in Germany. I grew up in the 70s/80s being told it is the worst country on earth. Also our view that being black in Africa in general was the worst fate. I remember that as quite the formative story of my childhood.

This was also one of few stories shared by both West and East Germany.

Now no one talks about SA at all anymore, of course.

But this fundamental story of the 70s about SA and how Germans are morally superior still lingers on.

Michelle Dostie's avatar

What a difference 5 decades makes! My introduction to Germany’s past began in the 50’s, (Diary of a Young Girl) at 10 years old, lasting through college textbooks on Nazism, and the Weimar Republic and into this decade. I came to understand Angela Merkof’s sorry decision (2015) in another text (The Strange Death of Europe) likely based on a desire to redeem the nation, but foolishly hurting the current populace. A political mistake by an otherwise sharp leader. Take us back to ‘75!

Andreas Stullkowski's avatar

In politics, it is a good rule to assume that the real reasons are usually not the moral justifications given to the population.

Merkel was the ultimate power politicians, with only one aim: being in power.

Here legacy, besides the economic and demographic disasters, is a political class constitued of low iq oportunists, who have a time horizon of a week.

The most infuriating thing bout them is their utter stupiditx.

This is illustread in many of Eugyppius articles here.

AwakeNotWoke's avatar

For many decades there was a massive international stigma about Germans even greater than the stigma that Israel under Netanyahu has today. Germans were seen as serial killers and perverts who turned victims into soap and lampshades. The stigma still exists in some countries in a strong form and in many other cases in a diluted form By re-igniting the "return of the Nazis" narrative in his portrayal of AfD, Merz risks bringing back the strong form of the international stigma.

EppingBlogger's avatar

Many new arrivals follow the Muslim books and theory. No problem for them in assuming the history of the Reich. They just don’t see it as guilt.

MR's avatar

And they are chomping at the bit to get it started up again!

Pat Robinson's avatar

They feel old Adolf was on the right track, just need to finish the job.

jan van ruth's avatar

they, like you, know nothing about old adolf.

Pat Robinson's avatar

i may know a bit, and good old Haj amin was one of the boys back in the day, they just want to continue his work as well.

Throgmorton's avatar

Arabic translations of Mein Kamph are freely on sale in the Middle East. The Muslim Brotherhood began in the 1920s as one of the many Fascist-style movements that sprang up all over Europe, though they dropped pan-Arabism for Islam.

jan van ruth's avatar

i fear you are not writing what you think you are writing...

i do not think the muslim brotherhood originated in europe...

and to equate pan arabism with fascism is a very great leap i really would like to see you elaborate on...

Cathy Carron's avatar

Read about the violence of Mohammed - violence seems to be part of the Islamic DNA

Richard Parker's avatar

I read the Book of Esther for the first time 6 weeks ago. It was a revelation.

Cathy Carron's avatar

A particularly violent story when the Jewish Esther revealed herself to her husband and requested that he protect her people. A grueling outcome but a defensive operation. Much like the 'Amalek' incident - after Moses helped the Jews out of Egypt they were attacked by the 'Amalites' - so they defended themselves.

jan van ruth's avatar

so the jews defended themselves against the amalites who attacked them?

the amalites being the population of the territory the jews were invading...

a striking resemblance with the situation in the palestine if the 20th. century.

jews invading and occupying the land of palestine, start victimising themselves because the inhabitants defend themselves, start to exterminate the original population, man, woman and child along with their animals and olive trees.

and so history repeats itself....

bedsides: moses is but a mythical figure, the exodus never happened.

god did not create man, man created god.

and he did so after his own image.

and he attributes his own words to his god.

"blot out the remembrance of amalek from under heaven"

it is not god who is a genocidal supremacist psychopath, it is the jew...

Richard Parker's avatar

G*d is too lazy to sort them out: Just kill them all.

jan van ruth's avatar

you do realise that it is in no way an historical essay?

it only reflects the state of mind of the writers....

jan van ruth's avatar

you have never heard of 'amalek"?

jan van ruth's avatar

so you know that violence is the essence of the 'jewish' dna....

Ryan Gardner's avatar

Everything has to be reduced to some faux moral imperative or outrage because it ensures first order thinking.

Hence the state of affairs in the west.

SCA's avatar

You know, I can't imagine anyone wanting to meld into Frenchness or Belgianness in the process of becoming a homogenized European.

And at the risk yet again of seeming suspiciously like a paid shill for Martyr Made, his ongoing series on The Germans' War, with its close examination of the atmosphere in Europe during and after WWI has very vividly and distressingly made me understand as much as anyone might who is only reading words what ordinary people endured and felt and were thrown into and motivated by. There were ongoing horrors everywhere, people fleeing from and migrating everywhere, and I guess there isn't much honest teaching of that anywhere. Though people revile Darryl Cooper enthusiastically, he quotes extensively from primary sources, the words of people who did actually live through and act within those times, and I think it would be fair to say nobody could remain normal under such conditions.

It would be a really good thing for the world if Germans as a people and Germany as a nation got their heads screwed on something approximating right (!!) because there is such a strong worthwhile culture foundational to German capacities. A Germany and an America that could help make one another more healthy again would be an incredible force in the world.

Gym+Fritz's avatar

I sometimes think that our perception of the 3rd reich & Hitler is an artificial construct, that prevents most of us from learning some of the most important lessons of the 20th century. What circumstances created Hitler and the Nazis, what were their positive accomplishments how and why did they go so wrong. I too am skeptical of M/M.

The current situation in Germany is a product of European politics, that is still surprisingly warlike, despite a common market, a common currency, open borders, NATO, the EU, demilitarization, and the dissolution of the USSR. The open ideological authoritarianism we currently see in Europe is not what the post war period was supposed to create.

SCA's avatar

The problem with Hitler was those of the men around him who were intelligent, capable and with normal moral faculties who nevertheless found him useful for their own purposes and failed to understand that you can never just get a little bit of crazy. Hitler attracted all sorts--the men who wanted a restored strong Germany that would never be humiliated again, and the guys who were every flavor of deranged.

The deranged faction gained the upper hand and Germany has paid for it ever after. And having lived through Our Plague Era with all the rest of us here assembled, I understand in my bones now how that happened. Decent people are at serious disadvantage against the other kind.

And re M/M: I really don't like his X self but his Substack self is remarkable. But people often show remarkably different sides of themselves depending on where and to what audience they may be posting.

Warmek's avatar

> failed to understand that you can never just get a little bit of crazy.

*looks back at dating history*

"Can confirm!"

Henrybowman's avatar

Change one or two words in your first paragraph and you've accurately described the condition of the US Democratic Party today. They catered to every fringe wacko imaginable, and imported millions of third world gibsmes and jihadists in order to become kings forevermore, and now all these groups are cooperating to wrest that power from the very people who invited them in.

SCA's avatar

The foundational problem of the postwar Democratic Party is believing in utopia and having the most rabid political theorists driving everything.

But my greatest ire is directed at the imaginary conservatives who allowed this to grow year after year after year. DEI nonsense was beginning to infest NYC elite private schools over 50 years ago. Luring the incapable into colleges, likewise. Failures of elementary level public education--well, that started in my experience in the '50s. Failure to enforce the immigration laws already on the books relating to public charge clauses etc., likewise.

That grand hero, Reagan, gave us the amnesty that transformed California into the horror it is now.

All the "grownups in the room" did was wear bowties and waggle their aristocratic eyebrows and get lots of speaking gigs and book contracts, and anyone is surprised the Democrats/progressives/lunatics took the ground they were ceded and ran with it?

SCA's avatar

Substack author Martyr Made (Darryl Cooper).

Charlotte's avatar

It’s probably an oversimplification of the subject, but a great start to helping to lift Germany out of the collective guilt, would be allowing citizens to proudly fly their flag again. And not just for World Cup matches. While we are at it, let’s get the UK to let folks fly their St. George flag too. Everybody else gets to fly their flags (Palestine, Turkey, Morocco, etc) within those countries just not their own. This demoralization has to end.

Hopefully, then there would be some introspection as to how inherently German characteristics (punctual trains, busses and exquisite mechanical engineering) are also being pounded out of the nation.

Warmek's avatar

It should never be forgotten that the first significant feat of the Germanic Tribes as recorded in Western History is that they annihilated three full Legions of the Romans.

And I don't mean that in a *bad* way. I am *lauding* their martial prowess.

The Battle of Teutoberg Forest. It even shares a remarkably poignant date, at least from the perspective of the Modern American.

AndyinBC's avatar

In the UK, "yesterday", absolute refusal to acknowledge the reality of today.

In Australia, "We're not British".

In Canada, "We're not American".

In Germany, "never again", the national guilt complex.

When did negativism become the core driver of belief systems in the formerly rich world?

Henrybowman's avatar

Compare with "Make America Great Again."

The mission statement of the right is typically positive, achievement based.

The mission statement of the left is typically negative. All the things they claim are wrong, all the things they oppose.

TDS. "Not my president." "Break your chains." "Eat the rich."

Lamp Post's avatar

I think BAP has it right when he points out that normative life paths in the developed world have an increasingly bad name (they are perceived as a bad deal overall by those participating in them), and it’ll be very difficult to motivate people to positively identify with these. The proliferation of what you call “negativism” might be a consequence of the uncompetitiveness of positive patriotic messaging among people whose primary experience of national life is not encouraging

Thucydides's avatar

This a remarkable and insightful analysis of the bizarre condition of German politics. Thanks!

Krispy Kris's avatar

Boss, I'm tired, but I just couldn't let this one go. I grew up in PA, where the "mother tongue" was not English—it was PA German, similar to Schwäbisch. My first visit to Germany was in '79 with a school chum, later in '83 and '84, with two "visits" to Landstuhl for "repairs" from my role in the Bush "GWOT." I moved to Germany in 2005 to be with my wife and children.

I've seen the changes. It's my opinion that the destruction of Germany started with "Mutti Merkel." She benefitted from the reforms of Schröder. Her "wir Schaffen das" was the start of the "suicidal empathy" as well as her "engergie Wende" that is responsible for the destruction of Germany as an Industrial powerhouse. It's my opinion, and so far, that's still my right in Germany to say that.

This situation is endemic to all western nations. It's difficult for me to explain without sounding like a conspiracy theorist. However, it all seems engineered. In 1963! there's a list of the 45 ways for the communists to destroy western nations. (https://1776history.com/2022/05/31/communisms-45-goals-for-america/)

To add to this is the corruption of the educational system with the elimination of Civics Class and the corruption of the annals of higher learning. Crikey, Qatar is a major funder of many major universities. When I talk about history to my German wife, she's missing a bit due to a "lack of teachers" in school—history, physics, and social sciences. When the "wir schaffen das" crap was broadcast, she was of the mind to say "we have so much, everyone deserves a piece of the pie."

Now, she/we are looking at retirement, and the rubber is hitting the road. She now is hit with the reality that she's worked for over 40 years and will get less than half or even less of what the "refugees" get from the social coffers.

No, there is no tranferrence of "generational guilt." My oldest son is in the Police, and sees the crisis of the "no-go zones." Our oldest daughter is in the "Jungentarmt" (Child services). She is expecting our second grandchild and sees the disparity of what the "refugees" receive in social benefits to what she and her man have to actually earn with their own energy to raise a family.

No, "generational guilt" is no longer a valid argument. Generational anger is, and it's no longer the sins of the fathers, but the sins of the government that are pissing the generations off. It's no wonder that they are demonising the AfD.

pebbleanttoast's avatar

I also did not grow up in Germany but now live here. I have spent much mental effort trying to understand Germans, especially during COVID.

I've come to the conclusion that the majority of Germans suffer from an unhealthy combination of several character traits: (1) easily propagandized via state media, (2) tendency to be pedantic know-it alls (superiority), (3) when told something is a rule then it's existence cannot be questioned and it will be followed, (4) a tendency for thoroughness in performing tasks, (5) collective decision making is often preferred, (6) getting money from the state, like subsidies, is great for one personally and totally unrelated to high taxes and inefficiency and waste

Krispy Kris's avatar

Funny that you mention "Propaganda." Once upon a time there was a radio that was offered for almost or actually free. It only broadcast the NSPD information, the "Volksempfänger," or as it was colloquially called the "Göbbelsschnauze." The German MSM is ironically little different. What I've seen is just the parroting of NWO crap from CNN, MSNOW, or other leftist media from the USA. Crikey, they even use the same videos. Oh, and for our readers outside of Germany, we actually have to pay a tax to see this crap.

I've lived here for over 21 years, and I've seen the decline. To point #2, yes, I deal with this daily. At home and at work. The parroting back of what is broadcast/printed by the modern Göbbelsschnauze is appalling. I just keep my head down since citing facts and giving real-world examples are a waste of energy, I'd never try to teach a pig to sing either.

To point #3. Cheese and Mother-fording rice. Germany has always been a country where if there's no sign to walk on the grass, it's forbidden. Getting a permit to do anything remains a Circus act of paperwork and documentation. Which also applies to #4, but that also is in my genes as well. I work as a mechanic, and my boss is enraptured with France. If I start anything, I require that all the materials are there to be able to start and finish a job properly. I had my own carpentry company and cabinet making shop, which both required "Meisterscheinen."

As far as points #5 and #6? Collective decision making on the level of folks working with their hands does not apply. #6? That's over my paygrade.

I'm genuinely thankful to live in an area with cows, sheep, and a few close friends who have pig farms. Incidentally, two of the ESSO stations in Kürten have no fuel to sell for the last two days.

pebbleanttoast's avatar

I should have been clearer. 5#: less likely to have a strong person in a position of leadership who makes decisions, instead there are always long discussions and group consensus decisions. #6: getting a heat pump for 40K with 20K in subsidies (which also leads to much higher prices than in neighboring countries), getting a subsidized often Chinese EV, doctors optimizing their financial well-being using every available method or loophole and plenty of other examples. There is a complete mental disconnect: people are totally happy to take the money and then complain endlessly about high taxes.

Throgmorton's avatar

Not a German speaker. Does "wir Schaffen das" mean what it sounds like in English? Because that is certainly what Merkel, the second-worst German Chancellor ever, did to Germany.

Krispy Kris's avatar

It's the same thing ironically that Bob the Builder used to say before everything he touched turned to Shite. Unfortunatly, Germany has no "Wendy" to come in to save the day.

Oh, it means "We can do it."

Vivian Evans's avatar

Thank you for this analysis, eugyppius. I would like to add that one reason, in my opinion, for the perpetuation of 'german guilt' into the now all-pervading foundational myth you describe, is the erasure from the general (or folk~) memory the existence of the German Resistance. Hands up anyone who can remember more names than just that of Stauffenberg! Books and contemporary memoirs are now unobtainable (I have a number of...). It is no wonder because in the DDR none of those names were permitted to be mentioned except the 'Rote Kapelle' because they were communists while in the BR a few names of those on the fringes were able to keep a few memories alive. Worst was, in the eyes of both states, the existence of what they sniffily labeled 'the officers' resistance'. You only need to know that it took a few years and hard work by the german politician Gerstenmayer to obtain widos' pensions for the wives of Stauffenberg and Tresckow - while the widows of Nazi generals received theirs without any trouble.

That tells you all: if the history and remembrance of the German Resistance - the so-called 'bürgerliche' as well as the 'communist' and the 'officers' resistance are swept under the carpet, not mentioned in living memories, then clearly, unlike in France where after the Fall of Paris 1944 every Frenchman and French woman had been in the Resistance, a Germans had been Nazis and thus have to bear that guilt even unto the fourth generation ...

But then, those who suppress or deny the teaching of History know precisely why they do it: a people without history has lost its roots and can more easily be eradicated.

Warmek's avatar

Hail the White Roses.

Throgmorton's avatar

The French Resistance were also Communist factions who were as likely to fight each other over ideological differences as to fight the occupation.

Quakeress's avatar

Mostly agree, I would just venture the hypothesis that this cult is a preoccupation of our chattering classes; most other people seem to have shaken it off or never even had it.

Jim Brown's avatar

Very thought-provoking. Thanks for your expert insight. So, the guilt cult is self-imposed, AND it is exploited by elected leaders. Immigrants to Germany can never assimilate into a "culture" because there really isn't one, in the sense of a positive historical mythos. I do not believe "nationalism" per se is negative. It depends on the nation's prevailing values. I do believe that for a nation to be successful through the generations, those values must be based on a positive view of man and of the culture he has created. Where the positive values for a New Germany will come from, I have no idea. Perhaps in that sense, the Germany we know is "done" and will be replaced by some other mythos.

Cathy Carron's avatar

When I was growing up in the 60s & 70s - Germans were known for precision and punctuality. I remember visiting German in the early 80s, taking a train to Rothenburg-ob-der-Tauber (recommended as a must-see by my high school German language teacher). And as the train pulled near, I observed the conductor looking at his schedule book making sure that he would be arriving exactly on time. I was so impressed. So recently, when I read that trains in Germany are rarely on time anymore.....it made me wonder if this was another symptom of malaise going on with the German public?

Pat Robinson's avatar

"Ordinary Germans participate in the Guilt Cult because they find it personally meaningful and because it constitutes an important part of their national identity."

Sort of like here in canada, where progressives base their identity on us having the worst performing health care system in the OECD, because its something they can proudly point to as "not american", and because they think like communists even tho they aren't smart enough to know they are communists, they base this system value on the fact that everyone gets the same crappy health care.

Point of pride that we are all equally screwed.

Except those of us that pop south as needed.

Richard Parker's avatar

My mom was Canadian. I live near several US national parks and I have started conversations with Canadians in these parks.

More of these Canadians than you would expect are in the USA for advanced health care unavailable in Canada.

Hans Niemand's avatar

Bismarck, ND here.

Maybe that's at least one of the reasons we have such good medical infrastructure in this area.

So, I suppose: Thanks, eh.

Pat Robinson's avatar

Many head south instead of waiting 18 months in line

Trish's avatar

The US has its own Guilt Cult, it’s called the Progressive Left

Cathy Carron's avatar

Doesn't hurt to repeat insight..... "The real threats to our political system are posed by the hostile migrants we’ve welcomed into our country and by an array of foolish anti-industrial policies that will destroy our economy us if they’re not unwound very soon."

Jack Gallagher's avatar

Typo? The word "us" in the last sentence: "...that will destroy our economy us if they’re not unwound very soon."

eugyppius's avatar

thanks, somehow an extraneous 'us' got in there.

Abner Knight's avatar

Hey AI. The guilt e writes about here sounds a lot like the guilt laid on young white males in the US. Who really controls Germany? Give me another version?

1945–1949: Direct Rule: The Allied Control Council exercised de jure sovereignty, filling the vacuum left by the collapse of the German Reich.

1949–1955: Conditional Sovereignty: The Occupation Statute codified a "middle state" where the FRG was allowed to govern internally, but remained subordinate to the Allied High Commission.

1955–Present: Chancellor Act: The final phase moves control from the legal realm to the structural. By anchoring the FRG into NATO, the European project, and the intelligence-sharing networks of the Five Eyes/Western security apparatus, the Allies moved from "occupying" to "managing" the state.